Skip to main content Skip to site footer
Match Reports

Plymouth Argyle 2 City 2 (5-3 pens)

Grecians beaten on penalties despite strong performance

3 October 2017

Sponsored by

Exeter City took a point from Home Park against Plymouth Argyle but missed out on gaining a bonus point in Group D of the Checkatrade Trophy.

The Grecians went ahead twice in the match but were pegged back by their fellow Devon counterparts, nonetheless City could take a number of positives from the match with a number of fringe players giving manager Paul Tisdale plenty of food for thought.

Tisdale made eight changes to the side that beat Morecambe 4-1 in League Two last weekend with the likes of James Hamon, Matt Jay, Kyle Edwards and Kane Wilson, who made his City debut, all looking to impress.

It was City who broke the deadlock first on 13 minutes when Liam McAlinden linked up well with Jay in the Pilgrim’s half.

The latter did well to play an exquisite pass through to his strike partner who finished coolly past Kyle Letheren.

But the Grecians weren’t ahead for long when they were pegged back on 19 minutes when defender Ryan Edwards rose well for a Plymouth corner to nod his side level in the match.

The home side continued to create good chances in the half with Nathan Blissett the danger-man for Plymouth who kept the likes of Troy Archibald-Henville and Luke Croll busy.

But City continued to threaten on the counter attack, often looking to use the pace of Jay, Edwards and Jack Sparkes to cause the damage, but credit to Letheren who was off his line quickly on more than one occasion to snatch the ball from the feet of the City forwards.

The second-half was a much more even affair with City sticking to their game plan. That plan worked well on 70 minutes when Tisdale’s side once again took the lead.

Edwards, who grew into the game, did well to skip past a Plymouth defender on the left-hand side a fire home a fantastic strike leaving Letheren with little chance of saving as the Grecians stormed in front.

But once again, Argyle continued to battle back and were behind for just five minutes when Blissett found himself in space centrally and slotted home past Hamon in the City goal.

The Grecians thought they’d won it right at the death when a cross from Edwards was flicked on by Jay, and his effort looped over the Argyle keeper but for the crossbar to deny the City number 20 of a winner.

With a point settled for both sides at the final whistle, it was left to the penalty shootout to decide who would earn the bonus point.

Unfortunately for the Grecians, Lloyd James’ penalty was saved low by Letheren and cool finishing from the home side sealed the extra point for Derek Adams’ team, despite the likes of Pierce Sweeney, Jay and Jake Taylor scoring well.

The Grecians now set their sights on getting back to league action this weekend as they face a trip to Carlisle United.

Plymouth Argyle: Letheren, Sawyer, Songo’o Edwards, Ness, Sarcevic, Carey (Lameiras, 67), Blissett (Ciftci, 90) , Jervis, Sokolik, Wylde

Subs not used: Cooper, Bradley, Grant, Taylor-Sinclair, Fletcher

Exeter City: Hamon, James, Archibald-Henville (Sweeney, 81), McAlinden, Jay, Moxey (Woodman, 67), Wilson, Croll, Edwards, Sparkes, Boateng (Taylor, 76)

Subs not used: Pym, Stockley, Reid, Brown


Advertisement block